Repeat? Perhaps.
Somehow, the 1st round predictions lacked a matchup settled via PK, so that's going to have to change. Here are my semifinal and final prognostications.
In the "East", we have a projected game between the DP-infused New York Red Bulls and striker-infused Colorado Rapids. In a one-game playoff, I'm just as scared of Omar Cummings and Conor Casey as I am Thierry Henry and Juan Pablo Angel, though the latter are a formidable tandem in their own right. This one will be in New York at pristine Red Bulls Arena, the second-best stadium in MLS come 2011. Home field gives NY a slight edge, but Colorado is dangerous. I see this one going to PKs after a 2-2 draw. Goals by, who else, Cummings and Casey for the Rapids and Dane Richards and former Rapid Mehdi Ballouchy for New York. Bouna Time shows up the shootout and eliminates his former club as Henry, Angel, Marquez, Lindpere and Chris Albright all connect for New York.
Out West we project an RSL-Seattle battle for a spot in the final. This match-up features the last two trophy winners (RSL MLS Cup '09 and Seattle US Open Cup '10) and some SERIOUS attacking prowess. Normally a team boasting Montero, Nkufo, Jaqua, Zakuani, Fernandez and Nyassi wouldn't have any trouble saying they were the most dangerous team in the building, but RSL can certainly hold its own with Saborio, Espindola, Findley, Morales, Johnson and Beckerman (when he wants to go forward). In my mind, the edge between these two teams will be in the home field advantage and RSL's stubborn back line (plus short but steady Nick Rimando). RSL squeeks by 2-1, on goals by Saborio and Johnson (both set up by Morales). Zakuani puts one home for Seattle on a break and keeps the
Daily Mirror pushing for his consideration in the England National Team.
This sets up an RSL-New York final at BMO Field in Toronto. Neither team is unfamiliar with the cold, so weather shouldn't be a factor no matter what November 21 in Toronto throws at them. RSL won the season series 1-0-1 after a 1-0 win at home and a 0-0 draw on the road. What does that confirm? Well, nothing. We already know Salt Lake doesn't give up many goals, but the Red Bulls were able to stifle the RSL attack to the tune of one goal through two games. Will this be a cagey contest? For some reason, I don't think so. Call it post-season adrenaline for the attackers or jitters for the defenders, but I think this game will open up.
New York opens the scoring through back-from-injury Henry, but Salt Lake answers almost immediately as Saborio says "this is my Newcomer of the Year award". RSL then pushes ahead after a beautiful free kick from Morales and shaky hands from Coundoul, before Angel caps his time in the big city with a calm finish after a Lindpere through ball. With time winding down, Salt Lake draws a corner kick and big Jamison Olave out-jumps rookie Tim Ream and place on in the upper 90 for a 3-2 Salt Lake victory as the Toronto fans go crazy.
That officially means that everyone from the Kansas City Wizards thinks Salt Lake will repeat. Good luck to them and everyone else still fighting for the trophy. In 2011 it's coming home with the Wizards.
*If all of the scores and goal-scorers above are correct, I'll pay for a round inside the supporters club once it opens next year. That surely won't happen, but it's pretty fun to attempt.